Tracklist
| A | Pencil Thin Mustache | 2:47 |
| B | Brand New Country Star | 2:40 |
Other versions
| Category | Artist | Title (Format) | Label | Category | Country | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| D-15011 | Jimmy Buffett | Pencil Thin Mustache (7", Fir) | Dunhill Records | D-15011 | US | 1974 |
| 5C 006-95946 | Jimmy Buffett | Pencil Thin Mustache (7") | Probe | 5C 006-95946 | Europe | 1974 |
| D-15011 | Jimmy Buffett | Pencil Thin Mustache (7", Promo) | ABC/Dunhill Records | D-15011 | US | 1974 |
| PRO-10625 | Jimmy Buffett | Pencil Thin Mustache (7", Promo) | Probe | PRO-10625 | Australia | 1974 |
| D-15011 | Jimmy Buffett | Pencil Thin Mustache (7", RP) | ABC/Dunhill Records | D-15011 | US | 1974 |
